Leave correlation out of a cost risk model and it will still produce a clean S-curve. It will just be too narrow, and the P80 and P90 will come out too low. This guide shows how large that effect is, and how to set correlation without pretending to precision you don't have.
Why independence makes the curve too narrow
In a simulation without correlation, every item draws its own luck. In one run the earthworks come in high and the steel comes in low, and the two cancel out. Across many items, those offsets add up to a total that barely moves. It's the same effect that makes a diversified investment portfolio more stable than a single share.
Real projects don't diversify like that. A rise in the steel price hits every steel-heavy item at once. Poor ground conditions hit the foundations, the excavation and the schedule together. When items move together, the bad runs stay bad, and the tail of the distribution gets longer.
The effect in numbers
To show it, we simulated a simple fictional estimate: eight cost items of $1.5M each, a base of $12.0M. Each item has the same range, from 10% below to 30% above its base. We ran it three times, each with 100,000 iterations and seed 42, changing only the correlation between the items.
| Correlation between items | Mean | P50 | P80 | P90 | Chance that base + 10% holds |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| None (independent) | $12.40M | $12.39M | $12.65M | $12.79M | 99% |
| 0.3, moderate | $12.40M | $12.37M | $12.85M | $13.11M | 92% |
| 0.6, strong | $12.40M | $12.35M | $12.99M | $13.34M | 87% |
Look at what changes, and what doesn’t.
- The mean doesn't change. Correlation leaves the expected cost exactly where it was. A model that only reports the mean will never show the problem.
- The tail does. The reserve needed above the base for P90 rises from $0.79M with independent items to $1.34M with a correlation of 0.6. That's about 70% more reserve, from one setting.
- The spread more than doubles. The standard deviation of the total goes from $0.30M to $0.69M.
The example is simplified on purpose: equal items and no risk events. On a real estimate the exact numbers differ, but the direction is always the same. In the fictional tunnel case of our QRCIM whitepaper, adding correlation barely moved the center of the distribution and clearly widened the tail.
How to set correlation without inventing precision
Nobody knows the correlation between two cost items to two decimals. You don't need to. What matters is the difference between "none" and "substantial". A coarse matrix with a handful of reasoned values is much closer to reality than an empty one. These are the guide values QRCIM shows on its correlation sheet:
| Situation | Guide value |
|---|---|
| Same material and same supplier | 0.7 to 0.9 |
| Same material, different supplier | 0.5 to 0.7 |
| Same weather or market exposure | 0.4 to 0.6 |
| Same discipline with related scope | 0.3 to 0.5 |
| Shared indirect costs | 0.2 to 0.4 |
| Unrelated disciplines | 0.0 to 0.2 |
Work by group rather than cell by cell: give all items within one block, such as civil works, the same value, and use a lower value between blocks for general market exposure. Record the reason for each non-zero value in your assumptions log.
Correlation in the Quantil tools
QRCIM lets you fill in a correlation matrix across up to fifty cost items and applies it with a Cholesky decomposition, the standard technique for drawing correlated values. The Cost & Schedule Risk Analyzer supports correlation between risks as well. The simulator on our homepage leaves it out on purpose, to keep the example simple. That's also why it's labeled simplified.